Who are some players who played on your team who also played for your rival?

  • By - 88T3

Image
ddbaxte

Babe Ruth. Johnny Damon and the traitor Jacoby Ellsbury.


Image
MillvilleMeteor

kevin youkilis 🤮


Image
Hochseeflotte

Andrew Miller as well.


Image
eatapenny

Nothing compares to the Stephen Drew for Kelly Johnson trade.


Image
Genisys_Arc

SpidermanPointing.jpg


Image
allaoc

Roger Clemens, Wade Boggs


Image
debauched_sloth_

How can you forget Yankees legend Adam Ottavino? Allegedly he's even better than the first guy on your list.


Image
acava2424

Mike Myers and Ethan Embree


Image
BRYankees7

Can’t leave out Alfredo Aceves here


Image
piopastaboy

Rickey Henderson and Mike Lowell.


Image
TheFriffin2

Phillies legend Pedro Martinez is much more well known for being a Mets star!


Image
PC_BUCKY

First of all....


Image
Dry_Log2445

He will always be a Montreal expo to me


Image
Dinoswarleaf

Kolten Wong lol all is forgiven


Image
meowens8505

I love him too much to be mad


Image
obviously8t

Orel Hershiser (Giants). That was just wrong.


Image
khodafez55

It hurt


Image
omegakukki

Joe Davis' son and I had the same reaction when we each found out.


Image
kevinm415

duke snider as well and jackie robinson was traded to the giants but chose to retire instead of play for us


Image
RudoWakening

I’m a White Sox fan. Sammy Sosa and George Bell each played for us and up north


Image
Tsnyda

Also as a Sox fan, Jim Thome always comes to mind as someone whom I hated when he played for Cleveland but loved when he played for the Sox.


Image
Ice_Like_Winnipeg

Magglio Ordonez is the first guy who comes to mind for me.


Image
johnofsteel

Billy McKinney.


Image
willofthemaster

Zach Wheeler for the Phillies. Glavine for the Braves. Yogi Berra for the Yankees.


Image
TheDandyWarhol

Eddie Rosario.


Image
Phillies2002

Jose Bautista (True story, folks)


Image
jessybumpapi

Alex Wood, Jake McGee, Tony Watson, Jason Schmidt, Orel Hershiser, Jeff Kent, Juan Uribe, Jack Clark, Brett Butler, Dusty Baker, Candy Maldonado…


Image
buddyhield_ama

Brian Wilson lol


Image
messick

Sergio Romo, for two different teams!


Image
yodaman5606

Sergio Romo, Russ Ortiz, Charlie Culberson, Guillermo Mota, Brad Penny, Cody Ross, Dave Roberts, Marquis Grissom, Brian Johnson...


Image
E70M

Indeed it does


Image
EffectiveCycle

Scott Rolen and Jim Edmonds


Image
KentuckyCactus

Ryan Ludwick, Edgar Renteria, Skip Schumaker


Image
JackeryA3

Same


Image
dangleswaggles

Johnny Damon, Hideki Matsui, Kelly Johnson, David Price, Grady Sizemore, Wade Boggs, Fred McGriff, Kelly Shoppach, our own manager, Jose Molina, that’s off the top of my head.


Image
88T3

Jonny Gomes, Eric Hinske, Manny Ramirez, Rocco Baldelli


Image
imuglywhenimpeein

Our coaching staff is full of traitors:


Image
Metfan722

Mets legend Kelly Johnson!


Image
Aaron_Fudge99

“Rival”


Image
DJstiles

Bryce Harper


Image
nuketoober27

Cardinals- Jim Edmonds, Ryan Theriot, Lee Smith


Image
JTCMuehlenkamp

You forgot Jason Heyward and Dexter Fowler.


Image
LovieBeard

You forgot Patrick Wisdom


Image
Cards2WS

John Lackey, Jon Jay, Daniel Descalso, Jason Motte, Shelby Miller, Jason Heyward...the list goes on and on of Cardinals/Cubs. Unsettling really


Image
88T3

Rays legend Matt Garza


Image
t9c75

Patrick Wisdom


Image
CrazyChestersDog

I mean who saw that coming though


Image
crisis_in_the_makin

Orel Hershiser!


Image
BlackCloudDiner143

Zack Britton


Image
dwhite21787

Mussina, Koji, Miller, WS MVP Steve Pearce


Image
NeverGetUpvoted

Hunter Pence


Image
willofthemaster

Beltran too. Even if they don't play much, I still consider the Cardinals a rival to the Astros


Image
successadult

Most recently, Robinson Chirinos.


Image
IAmTrident

Josh Hamilton


Image
Drazzo00

Tom Glavine, Braves/Mets


Image
Cornflakesforfools

Glavine hurts, but there’s a big list of dudes to play for both. We can’t forget d’Arnaud nor can we let him forget.


Image
HoracioPeacockThe3rd

not a current example (not sure if there are any?) but i was always a fan of how kelly johnson went braves-mets-braves-mets


Image
Blind_Umpire899518

Dan Uggla “played” for the Braves as a Marlins sleeper operative


Image
TheSalsaGod

Lou Brock


Image
GodPowardKingOfLies

Jason Heyward


Image
dr_pepper50

David Price


Image
Prize_Major6183

Cubs legends Shelby Miller, Lou Brock, Patrick Wisdom, Jim Edmonds


Image
Cards2WS

The Cubs took a shot at rekindling some magic from those early 2010’s Cardinal teams...Jon Jay, Daniel Descalso, Jason Motte, John Lackey, and Shelby Miller have all played for the Cubs


Image
Im_Daydrunk

Brian Wilson and Jeff Kent come to mind


Image
E70M

Orel Hershiser, Juan Marichal, Dave Roberts, Jeff Kent, Alex Wood, Jake McGee, Tony Watson... I could go on


Image
HephaestusClangBang

Kolten Wong.


Image
gh234ip

Tommy John pitched for the Dodgers when they lost to the Yankees in 1978, while Jay Johnstone played for the Yankees that year. In 1981 Tommy John was a pitcher for the Yankees who lost to the Dodgers who happened to have one Jay Johnstone on their roster.


Image
Rudeyyyy

Postseason MVP Daniel Murphy signed with the Nats when he hit FA instead of resigning with us because the Wilpons didn’t want to pay him.


Image
Kaydom1993

Murph, Asdrúbal, Wheeler, d’arnaud, Beltran, Grandy Man


Image
avmp629

Ichiro


Image
dnovi

Steve Pearce.


Image
dwhite21787

Joey Bats


Image
Shiftylee

Mark Bellhorn


Image
ricky_burns

Roger Clemens, AJ Burnett, Vernon Wells, Eric Hinske, I think Lyle Overbay briefly, the list goes on


Image
Dmt123410

Mussina, Britton


Image
dwhite21787

Reggie


Image
Competitive_Day_7907

BJ Ryan, David price, aj Burnette, Lyle overbay


Image
imuglywhenimpeein

Ji-Man Choi, Rich Hill, and Chaz Roe were all Yankees at one point. Hill, Jalen Beeks, and Jeffrey Springs were all Red Sox (as was Collin McHugh, though he never played in a game for them).


Image
Dh873

Mike Mussina, Reggie Jackson, David Wells, Jimmy Key, Brian Roberts, Zach Britton. Tony Tarasco, which is just sickening.


Image
dwhite21787

Tim Beckham


Image
DarbyDown

Andy Messersmith was a stud for the Angels snd Dodgers.


Image
LibertarianSocialism

Reddick, Lowrie, Fiers, Laureano (in their system)


Image
WhoaItsAFactorial

Mike Mussina. Zack Britton.


Image
RstortonYT

Rickey Henderson


Image
mungdungus

Maybe more than any other player, I hated seeing Paul Quantrill as a Yankee.


Image
SnoochPowders

AJ Pierzynski. I still loved watching him talk shit and foul off 10 pitches every at-bat, though.


Image
ZarosGuardian

Jason Werth is one I think of right off the bat, along with JT Realmuto, Jose Alfaro, Zack Wheeler, and Bryce Harper.


Image
Sheepies123

Kelly Johnson and Juan Uribe


Image
Poncahotas

Torii Hunter, Victor Martinez, Magglio Ordonez


Image
torontomua

eric sogard


Image
Frost99

Vladdy just raked against us for years but made up for it all in 2010


Image
Gyakudo

Ichiro.


Image
tristpa2

Tommy LaStella :(


Image
Dry_Log2445

Tom glavine had a few seasons with the Mets and it was sacrilegious


Image
Crabpeople-99

Aramis Ramirez had a few really good years with the Brewers near the end of his career. Spent his entire career in the NL Central if I'm not mistaken


Image
KrazeeTapper

Nasty Nate (Eovaldi) and Adam Ottovino


Image
the_seed

Travis Fryman


Image
Tsquare43

Candy Maldonado


Image
Competitive_Day_7907

Albert Pujols


Image
Xlyria

Joe Crede


Image
PPLH8ER420

George Springer but he hasn’t played much for the Jays


Image
JrpgGamer

I wouldn't consider the Jays a rival tho